[a12k]

Fixes gh-143620

There is a race condition in test_concurrent_futures.test_process_pool. The test asserts that a BrokenProcessPool exception has a __cause__ immediately after future.result() raises.

In concurrent.futures.process, the _terminate_broken method sets the exception on the future before it attaches the _RemoteTraceback to the __cause__ attr. Sometimes the test thread wakes up and inspects the exception while __cause__ is still None, which leads to a test failure. I was able to repro (see issue for more details) by injecting a delay in _terminate_broken between the set_exception() call and the __cause__ assignment. This causes a 100% failure rate with AssertionError: None is not an instance of _RemoteTraceback.

My proposed fix is to update the test to use support.sleeping_retry to wait for the __cause__ to be populated. This seems to be the pattern elsewhere in the test suite.

[WYSIATI]

I think the race condition analysis here may be slightly off. Looking at _terminate_broken(), bpe.__cause__ is assigned on line 493 before set_exception() on line 498, so the test thread shouldn't be able to see __cause__ as None due to ordering.

The actual issue seems to be that when cause is None (the os._exit path), p.exitcode can still return None at line 487 because waitpid() hasn't collected the exit status yet — even though the process sentinel has already fired. This means errors stays empty, cause_str stays None, and bpe.__cause__ is never set at all.

A sleeping_retry in the test won't help here because nobody goes back to set __cause__ after the fact — once _terminate_broken() finishes, the exception is final.

A fix in _terminate_broken() itself might work better — calling p.join(timeout=3) before reading p.exitcode would ensure waitpid() has collected the exit status:

for p in self.processes.values():
    p.join(timeout=3)
    if p.exitcode is not None and p.exitcode != 0:
        errors.append(...)

The sentinel has already fired at this point so join() should return almost immediately. This way p.exitcode is reliably available when we read it.

[github-actions]

This PR is stale because it has been open for 30 days with no activity.