Skip to content

Data export button for Admins #17

Closed

Description

@fankijo

Hello,

it would be nice if there is a button for the Admins to export all the Data for one user.

Activity

  1. blizzz commented on Jun 12, 2018

    @blizzz
    Member

    That's a long journey, and the infrastructure for it needs to be implemented in the server. This is also the way we want to do it, whether it'll happen with 14 is not sure yet. For a long answer see https://help.nextcloud.com/t/gdpr-support-possibility-to-export-import-users/32311/5

  2. jgrete commented on Aug 14, 2018

    @jgrete

    Hmm, on
    https://nextcloud.com/gdpr/
    it sounds completely different. Everybody reading that webpage will come to the conclusion that data export on user demand is just a snap.
    It isn't like that - instead we have to go a different path to fulfill at least some GDPR requirements (database export - upgrade hell is waiting...). Even the (self)deletion of a user is not complete as far as I can see. So to avoid the nasty smell of vaporware one should clearly mark a missing feature as 'planned'/'nice to have' or implement it.
    Just my 2ct
    Juergen

  3. jospoortvliet commented on Aug 14, 2018

    @jospoortvliet
    Member

    @jgrete we have extensive documentation that helps with this, see https://portal.nextcloud.com for download. Yes, it isn't automated - that is something we work on, as Arthur noted, but it will take time and depends on the apps implementing support so it will never be 100% complete.

    However, in the docs we have all the commands you need to write etc etc etc... so that should help a lot, make it just a checklist-affair. And if there's a real need, for example for a large company dealing with lots of requests, we're happy to help a customer script it or even built what they need.

    Also, I don't think that in any way, anywhere, we suggest that it is just a one-click thing. We explicitly say that the data request app is just that - a request:
    "Data Request app to allow users to request data deletion or modification from their user settings"

    But if there's anywhere else a sentence or otherwise a suggestion that is incorrect, please let me know so I can fix it!

  4. jgrete commented on Aug 14, 2018

    @jgrete

    @jospoortvliet I must admit I never was on portal.nextcloud.com and just discovered how to find it. I looked at https://nextcloud.com/gdpr/ and I tried to get the whitepaper promised there. I tried it with different email addresses but never got it sent to me. And yes I dived down to the bottom of my junk folder looking for the paper - no success.
    We are trying to be prepared for requests like this but have no idea how many that will be. For now we decided to export each and every record of each and every table where a column named like user/user_id/... can be found if the user matches that row contens. I'm quite sure this won't give us the complete dataset for the user as the GDPR requires - but I don't see how to handle it in a different way.

    Thanks a lot for the hints!
    Jürgen

    EDIT: Where exactly can I find those papers? I searched for GDPR - no success. I scrolled all documents on portal.nextcloud.com I could find - no success :-(

  5. MorrisJobke commented on Aug 20, 2018

    @MorrisJobke
    Member

    EDIT: Where exactly can I find those papers? I searched for GDPR - no success. I scrolled all documents on portal.nextcloud.com I could find - no success :-(

    The white paper links in the portal are there for logged in users. Customer of the Nextcloud Subscription will get access to this logged in part. Otherwise the whitepapers are only available on the website at https://nextcloud.com/gdpr/. Maybe Jos can check what's wrong there if it doesn't sent you the link.

  6. pieter-groeneweg commented on Aug 20, 2018

    @pieter-groeneweg

    I do have this document "General GDPR overview". On page 7 is states:

    Data in Nextcloud can be found in various areas. See the GPDR
    Admin Manual for an overview of those locations and how to extract
    the data.

    Where can I find this manual? I cannot find it in the online admin manual for Nextcloud.

  7. kevinkk525 commented on Jan 27, 2019

    @kevinkk525

    Little ping for this topic.
    A method for exporting user data would be really good.

  8. mwuttke commented on Apr 23, 2019

    @mwuttke

    Hello,
    is there any progress at this point?
    Thanks & Greetings,
    Michael

  9. Utopiah commented on Nov 3, 2019

    @Utopiah

    Would https://apps.nextcloud.com/apps/data_request do the job? OK so... no apparently it only send an email for manual export for the admin.

  10. jgrete commented on Nov 4, 2019

    @jgrete

    I wonder if somebody else tested the GDPR compliance already...
    Deleting users on demand and reporting data usage of user data could be a major advantage as the lack of it could be a disaster. I think this should be done within the NC core and not by an app.
    But I'm not very confident that something will happen in the very near future as after one year has passed I cant't see much progress

  11. kevinkk525 commented on Nov 4, 2019

    @kevinkk525

    Sadly true despite the fact that such a request would be a nightmare for every admin, manually searching the database for user data and exporting it in an acceptable format.
    At least deleting a user is no trouble (unless not all personal data gets removed? like comments, etc?)

  12. jgrete commented on Nov 4, 2019

    @jgrete

    @kevinkk525 : At least you have to check randomly that a users data is deleted entirely or report records that cannot be deleted (because other users are affected). And you have to repeat that check on every update or check that the database scheme is unaltered. We do not have that much off-boarding yet, but this might become a problem in the future.

  13. jospoortvliet commented on Dec 7, 2019

    @jospoortvliet
    Member

    I do have this document "General GDPR overview". On page 7 is states:

    Data in Nextcloud can be found in various areas. See the GPDR
    Admin Manual for an overview of those locations and how to extract
    the data.

    Where can I find this manual? I cannot find it in the online admin manual for Nextcloud.

    This is only available on our portal, in other words, for customers. Private users should not have much need for this, enterprises - well, either they can become customers and get access to our expertise, or they can spend their paid time to figure these things out by themselves, either way, running software costs money.

    We help our customers handle these requests - it is largely a manual process the first time as it depends on the customers' infrastructure, apps etcetera, so it costs us some time to put things together (in a script or something like that) for them.

  14. Utopiah commented on Dec 9, 2019

    @Utopiah

    Nobody is arguing that software and its maintenance is free so this is not the point. Of course quality work should be compensated fairly.

    Private users should not have much need for this

    Doesn't that imply then that there is a vendor and infrastructure lock-in by design? If exporting to another Nextcloud instance or even an open format of a user account is not straightforward then all the communication about control on user data seems misleading.

  15. rugk commented on Jan 24, 2021

    @rugk

    Well… as a user you can at least export all stuff from your Nextcloud with a few more steps. Files, ical etc. are all possible to export and import again. You just need to press some more buttons in the UI. So, yeah, maybe some settings are not (though these are usually not covered by such exports anyway, as they are not personal data as per the GDPR).

  16. Utopiah commented on Jan 27, 2021

    @Utopiah

    all possible to export and import again. You just need to press some more buttons in the UI.

    As mentioned just above the question isn't much about if it's possible or not but rather how to make it convenient. If for every new service used there is another import/export manual cycle then the incentive to use more services from NextCloud decreases instead of becoming constant, or even increasing. I believe specifically for users who decide to user a solution that is not the de facto standard, e.g. not Google Docs or Microsoft 365 or iCloud then we can assume being able to conveniently move data around or at the very least not feel trapped matters. I can safely it does matter for me.

  17. max-nextcloud commented on May 2, 2023

    @max-nextcloud
    Collaborator

    The actual data import and export is covered by the user_migration app.
    It provides occ commands for admin use. If you need a graphical user interface rather than a command line tools please open a feature request there.

    This app only covers the use case of requesting account deletion or data export as in particular large organizations have custom workflows for this.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions