You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
{{ message }}
Repository navigation
[Currency Exchange] Confusing Wording and Directions #2621
The actual coding work is extremely easy, it's just basic arithmetic. The problem is understanding what you are supposed to be calculating. Everything is easy until task 5, when you-know-what hits the fan, at least for me. In the beginning, budget was a total, and we were just taking a portion out of it to be used, with exchanging value and such. Now it appears we are spending it all in one place? Then comes in denomination. Is this the denomination of the original bill or the new foreign bill? And are we getting the number of original bills or new foreign bills. I'm sorry for being disorganized but I am stumped by this exercise even though it is seemingly a simple concept.
Reacted by ib1905, Vinicius Antonio do Nascimento, Andrew Peterson and epyklion
Thanks for logging this. @epyklion - thanks for commenting. 🌟 🌈
Please take a look at the discussion in Issue 2591 (now closed as fixed by PR 2601). I think some of the comments there might help clarify things a bit.
We'd also love if you have any suggestions or thoughts on how to improve this exercise, since it seem to be giving people lots of issues -- despite us having re-written it a couple of times.
Comments (or a PR) of what you think might be a better fit with the story and the tasks (numbers) would be warmly welcomed. 😄
Would it be a bad thing to just say "to calculate this you need to take the quotient of x and y and then find the product of the resulting number and z"? It would shift the focus of the problem from trying to comprehend currency exchange to implementing mathematical equations and working with numbers.
Reacted by ib1905 and Vinicius Antonio do Nascimento
Would it be a bad thing to just say "to calculate this you need to take the quotient of x and y and then find the product of the resulting number and z"? It would shift the focus of the problem from trying to comprehend currency exchange to implementing mathematical equations and working with numbers.
I think it would be better to have some aspect of identifying the problem, but add in hints for every step that point you in the right direction.
Since we're being slow in re-writing this exercise and decided to merge #2804, I am going to close this issue as resolved -- until we re-design/re-write the exercise.
Activity
epyklion commentedon Oct 2, 2021
I agree and if possible, can anyone clearly explain to me task 5 and 6
BethanyG commentedon Oct 2, 2021
Hi @BrooksAz 👋🏽
Thanks for logging this. @epyklion - thanks for commenting. 🌟 🌈
Please take a look at the discussion in Issue 2591 (now closed as fixed by PR 2601). I think some of the comments there might help clarify things a bit.
We'd also love if you have any suggestions or thoughts on how to improve this exercise, since it seem to be giving people lots of issues -- despite us having re-written it a couple of times.
Comments (or a PR) of what you think might be a better fit with the story and the tasks (numbers) would be warmly welcomed. 😄
Bixxith commentedon Oct 3, 2021
Would it be a bad thing to just say "to calculate this you need to take the quotient of x and y and then find the product of the resulting number and z"? It would shift the focus of the problem from trying to comprehend currency exchange to implementing mathematical equations and working with numbers.
[-]Currency Exchange is confusing[/-][+][Currency Exchange] Confusing Wording and Directions[/+]BrooksAz commentedon Oct 3, 2021
I think it would be better to have some aspect of identifying the problem, but add in hints for every step that point you in the right direction.
BrooksAz commentedon Oct 4, 2021
I have created a pull request which I think clears up a lot of the vagueness that currently exists in the exercise.
BethanyG commentedon Oct 4, 2021
@BrooksAz -- could you please link that PR to this issue? Many thanks. 🌟 I will try to review & comment on it later today my time (I am in PST).
BrooksAz commentedon Oct 4, 2021
#2626 Right here
BethanyG commentedon Nov 25, 2021
Please see also issue #2804 (closed in favor of tracking feedback here), which has additional feedback and comments for improvement.
BethanyG commentedon Dec 14, 2021
Since we're being slow in re-writing this exercise and decided to merge #2804, I am going to close this issue as resolved -- until we re-design/re-write the exercise.