Skip to content

[Bug]: modifying Hexagonal layout breaks it #795

Closed

Description

@rkdikshan-commits

Preliminary Verification

  • I have searched existing open and closed issues and discussions to verify this bug is not already reported.
  • I have tested or verified this behavior on the latest release or beta version.
  • I have tried clearing app cache or testing with default settings.

Description of the Bug

So i was trying to modify the hexagonal layout (because i want to create dvorak varient) and that's when i discovered that even slightly modifying breaks it.
Heck even copying the honeycomb json code that already leantype uses and pasting it in different layout breaks it.

Steps to Reproduce

Go to settings
Language and layouts
Active keyboards english
Under config layouts
Press edit paste the hexagon json code

You can also select TypeWise honeycomb layout
Change say a single letter to another letter and it breaks

[
  [
    { "label": "w", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "e", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "1" } } },
    { "label": "t", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "2" } } },
    { "label": "z", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "3" } } },
    { "label": "i", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "4" } } },
    { "label": "o", "width": 0.142857 }
  ],
  [
    { "label": "q", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "a", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "r", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "5" } } },
    { "label": "g", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "6" } } },
    { "label": "u", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "7" } } },
    { "label": "l", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "p", "width": 0.142857 }
  ],
  [
    { "label": "shift", "width": 0.071429, "hexVariant": 1 },
    { "label": ",", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "'" }, "relevant": [{ "label": "-" }] } },
    { "code": 32, "label": " ", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "f", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "8" } } },
    { "label": "h", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "9" } } },
    { "code": 32, "label": " ", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": ".", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "!" }, "relevant": [{ "label": "?" }] } },
    { "label": "delete", "width": 0.071429, "hexVariant": 2 }
  ],
  [
    { "label": "y", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "s", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "d", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "n", "width": 0.142857, "popup": { "main": { "label": "0" } } },
    { "label": "m", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "j", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "k", "width": 0.142857 }
  ],
  [
    { "label": "x", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "c", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "v", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "b", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "symbol_alpha", "width": 0.142857 },
    { "label": "action", "width": 0.142857 }
  ]
]

Expected Behavior

It should maintain the honeycomb layout

Logs / Crash Report

No response

Build Flavor

Standard (with local AI, voice, and OCR support)

App Version

V4.3.2

Device & Android Version

Tried it in other devices its not android or device specific issue

Target App (if applicable)

No response

Screenshots or Screen Recordings

No response

Activity

  1. changed the title [-][Bug]: Hexagonal layout[/-] [+][Bug]: modifying Hexagonal layout breaks it[/+] on Nov 13, 2026
  2. rkdikshan-commits commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @rkdikshan-commits
    Author

    For help I asked claude and looks like it has a simple fix

    The Problem
    Right now, copying the default Typewise Honeycomb JSON from LeanType’s settings and pasting it directly into a Custom Layout slot breaks the keyboard. Because the hexagonal renderer and axial hit-tester only trigger for hardcoded built-in IDs (hex_typewise / hex_qwerty), custom layouts get routed through the standard rectangular grid parser—which breaks on the 0.857-width outer rows (6 × 0.142857) and hexVariant half-keys.

    ​Simple Fixes (Pick Any One)

    1. Auto-detect via hexVariant (Zero schema or UI changes):
      LeanType’s existing honeycomb JSON already uses "hexVariant": 1 (shift) and "hexVariant": 2 (delete) on Row 3. In the custom layout loader, checking whether any key defines hexVariant (e.g., rows.flatten().any { it.hexVariant != null }) is enough to route the layout to the hexagonal renderer instead of the rectangular one. Existing honeycomb JSONs will work out of the box when copied and modified.

    2. Add a "Hexagonal Grid" toggle (or hex_ name prefix):
      If explicit selection is preferred over auto-detection, add a simple Grid Shape: Rectangular / Honeycomb switch in the Custom Layout editor—or trigger the hex engine whenever a custom layout name starts with hex_ (e.g., hex_dvorak).

  3. rkdikshan-commits commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @rkdikshan-commits
    Author

    Easiest way to reproduce this bug is just change the name of working honeycomb layout.

  4. LeanBitLab commented on Nov 14, 2026

    @LeanBitLab
    Owner

    there will be an beta release in 30 minutes if it didnt fixed it ill reopen the issue

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    bugSomething isn't working

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions